The Philippine Supreme Court and the Mining Act ruling reversal
Date
2006
Authors
Contributor
Advisor
Department
Instructor
Depositor
Speaker
Researcher
Consultant
Interviewer
Narrator
Transcriber
Annotator
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Honolulu: East-West Center
Volume
Number/Issue
Starting Page
Ending Page
Alternative Title
Abstract
In January 2004, the Philippine Supreme Court nullified provisions of the Philippine Mining Act of 1995 which allowed foreign mining firms to operate in the country. In December of the same year, the Court reversed its January ruling to the dismay of environmentalists, advocates of indigenous peoples' rights, and opponents of economic liberalization. What accounts for the Court reversal? How does one explain the Philippine Supreme Court's overturning of its very own ruling? The paper explores the factors that contributed to the Supreme Court reversal. The author first conducted an analysis of the text of the Court's two rulings. The aim of the content analysis was to compare and contrast the articulated bases of the Court's January and December rulings. The author then examined the reversal in relation to factors that affect judicial outcomes. According to Paul Wahlbeck, these factors are: (1) judicial preferences, (2) legal constraints, (3) litigation environment, and (4) political environment. According to a Filipino legal luminary, the December reversal resulted from a change in the Court's choice of approach to constitutional interpretation—that is, from a textual and historical approach to a prudential and structural approach. The adoption of a different approach to constitutional interpretation however partly explains the court reversal. The change in the choice of interpretative approach still begs the question: What occasioned the adoption of a new approach to constitutional interpretation and hence the court reversal?
Description
For more about the East-West Center, see http://www.eastwestcenter.org/
Keywords
Philippines. - Supreme Court, Mining law - Philippines
Citation
Extent
13 pages
Format
Geographic Location
Time Period
Related To
Related To (URI)
Table of Contents
Rights
Rights Holder
Local Contexts
Email libraryada-l@lists.hawaii.edu if you need this content in ADA-compliant format.