Testing the Availability of Universal Grammar in Second Language Acquisition: The Governing Category Parameter and the Proper Antecedent Parameter in Japanese as a Second Langauge
Testing the Availability of Universal Grammar in Second Language Acquisition: The Governing Category Parameter and the Proper Antecedent Parameter in Japanese as a Second Langauge
Date
1990
Authors
Shimura, Akihiko
Contributor
Advisor
Department
University of Hawaii at Manoa. Department of English as a Second Language.
Instructor
Depositor
Speaker
Researcher
Consultant
Interviewer
Annotator
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Volume
Number/Issue
Starting Page
Ending Page
Alternative Title
Abstract
To solve the logical problem of L1 acquisition, a domain-specific Universal Grammar (UG) has been proposed. Is UG also available in adult SLA? There are three competing hypotheses with regard to this question in SLA literature: (1) the UG-Subset Principle Hypothesis (U-SPH), (2) the UG-Transfer Hypothesis (U TH), and (3) the Fundamental Difference Hypothesis (FDH). They appear to be all theoretically motivated and empirically supported in the literature.
Two studies with experimental designs were devised to systematically compare and test these three hypotheses to answer the question of the availability of UG in adult SLA. In the first study, the acquisition of he Proper Antecedent Parameter h Japanese as a Second Language (JSL) was investigated in order to compare the U-SPH with the U-TH and the FDH, while the second study looked at the acquisition of the Governing Category Parameter in JSL in order to compare the U-SPH and the U-TH with the FDH. 48 native-speakers of English worked on a picture identification task in these studies. 16 native speakers (NS) of Japanese and 16 NSs of English also participated as control groups.
The results of the two studies supported the Fundamental Difference Hypothesis, which proposes that UG is no longer available in its entirety in SLA. UG is available only through L1. Suggestions were also made for the future research.
To solve the logical problem of L1 acquisition, a domain-specific Universal Grammar (UG) has been proposed. Is UG also available in adult SLA? There are three competing hypotheses with regard to this question in SLA literature: (1) the UG-Subset Principle Hypothesis (U-SPH), (2) the UG-Transfer Hypothesis (U TH), and (3) the Fundamental Difference Hypothesis (FDH). They appear to be all theoretically motivated and empirically supported in the literature.
Two studies with experimental designs were devised to systematically compare and test these three hypotheses to answer the question of the availability of UG in adult SLA. In the first study, the acquisition of he Proper Antecedent Parameter h Japanese as a Second Language (JSL) was investigated in order to compare the U-SPH with the U-TH and the FDH, while the second study looked at the acquisition of the Governing Category Parameter in JSL in order to compare the U-SPH and the U-TH with the FDH. 48 native-speakers of English worked on a picture identification task in these studies. 16 native speakers (NS) of Japanese and 16 NSs of English also participated as control groups.
The results of the two studies supported the Fundamental Difference Hypothesis, which proposes that UG is no longer available in its entirety in SLA. UG is available only through L1. Suggestions were also made for the future research.
Description
Keywords
universa grammar,
transfer,
fundamental difference,
adult second language acquisition,
japanese as a second language,
parameters
Citation
Extent
135 pages
Format
Geographic Location
Time Period
Related To
Table of Contents
Rights
Rights Holder
Local Contexts
Collections
Email libraryada-l@lists.hawaii.edu if you need this content in ADA-compliant format.