ScholarSpace will be brought offline for upgrades on Wednesday December 9th at 11AM HST. Service will be disrupted for approximately 2 hours. Please direct any questions to

Item Description

Show full item record

Title: WRRCTR No.120 The Enforcement of Consistency in Hawaiian Water Rights: An Introduction to Robinson v. Ariyoshi 
Author: Chang, Williamson B.C.
Date: 1978-06
Publisher: Water Resources Research Center, University of Hawaii at Manoa
Citation: Chang WBC. 1978. The enforcement of consistency in Hawaiian water rights: an introduction to Robinson v. Ariyoshi. Honolulu (HI): Water Resources Research Center, University of Hawaii at Manoa. WRRC technical report, 120.
Abstract: One of the most critical questions regarding the future of water regulation in Hawai'i is the validity of the Hawaii Supreme Court's
decision in the landmark case of McBryde Sugar Co. v. Robinson. In that case, the state supreme court overturned the assumption that surface waters in Hawai'i could be privately owned. To the parties involved in
the litigation, the decision came as a surprise and upset the basis for their claims to waters of the stream. As a result, the parties sought to have the results of the state supreme court decision nullified in
federal court. Their efforts were successful, and in October 1977, the federal district court voided the state supreme court decision. This article challenges the validity of the federal court's decision. The
question presented before the federal court was a novel and unique one.
The article discusses three models for resolving the problem and discusses an important distinction between the function of courts in declaring law and enforcing their judgments.
Series/Report No.: WRRC Technical Report
Sponsorship: Office of Water Research and Technology, U.S. Dept. of the Interior Grant/Contract No. A-074-HI
Pages/Duration: vii + 24 pages
Keywords: water law, water rights, Federal jurisdiction, State jurisdiction, legal aspects, judicial decisions, litigation, Hawaii, McBryde v. Robinson, Robinson v. Ariyoshi
LC Subject Headings: Water rights -- Hawaii.
Water -- Law and legislation -- Hawaii.

Item File(s)

Files Size Format View
wrrctr120.pdf 1.380Mb PDF View/Open

This item appears in the following Collection(s)


Advanced Search


My Account